Thursday, March 11, 2010

My Season 9 American Idol Picks - Top 12


**How could Lilly be gone??! As she said, "There's a lot of incredible talent going home tonight." I am very disappointed to see certain people stay over others. Todrick had more to give, but I do agree he may be better suited for Broadway (which would give him more opportunity to showcase all his talents anyway). Katelynn Epperly was not the strongest competitor but I honestly thought she was staying when they had her standing with Paige. Poor Alex Lambert! He was torn up and couldn't hide it. He was getting better but definitely needed more performance with the vocals.


TOP 12

Didi Benami: Love her, she has such an awesome sound and knows how to use her voice.
Siobhan Magnus: I can't deny her vocal skills but she is odd in an off-putting kind of way.
Paige Miles: Again, bomb voice but little connection to her when she sings, either cuz her lack of connection with the song or maybe what she fails to project to the audience.
Crystal Bowersox: Totally deserves to be in the top 12. She is a true artist.
Lacey Brown: Um, not so much worthy of the top 12 title. Should've been Katelynn.
Katie Stevens: Also not ready for this top 12 group. Should've been Lilly.

Casey James: Great vocals, great musician and a simple artist.
Tim Urban: I don't think he should be top 12. His song this week was an easy vocal and he has failed to impress otherwise.
Lee Dewyze: So worthy of top 12. He's awesome and should go far.
Michael Lynche: Wow, that Maxwell song was absolutely amazing and touching. I couldn't believe his range and control in that falsetto. Saw him in a new light after that.
Aaron Kelly: Yeah...why??
Andrew Garcia: Of course, he should be top 12 and I hope he keeps being himself and showing us how talented he really is.


No comments:

Post a Comment